SiIvaGunner Wiki:Meme discussion/Log/19th: Wii Shop Bling
Per the moot, this serves to address the category Rips referencing Wii Shop Bling, and whether it should be converted to a normal meme category, i.e. Rips featuring Wii Shop Bling.
History/Current situation regarding the category (from the moot):
This was... apparently not approved in a moot? https://discord.com/channels/787504555763826738/787504555801051172/1195131423544311808 This appears to be the conversation that led to its creation. For some reason, all of the participants agree that this category will also mean Wii Shop Bling gets a meme page, despite the fact that up to this point we've been using this category type explicitly for things that are not considered memes.
Note for clarity: Since the category already exists, "oppose" in this context means "do nothing". If one believes this should not be categorized at all, that is a restructure.
- Support: Video external to the channel that is referenced via paired sources. This is literally no different from MARIO BROTHERS MOVIE.
~~ i think this is different from athletic doctor since the rip "Main Theme - Wii Shop Channel" is based on the original mashup by toonlink. I agree that this category should be renamed, but also think that the afformentioned rip should be included in this category.~~ (see https://discord.com/channels/787504555763826738/1363335604863111298/1363338677467484303)
mario brothers movie is not equal to wii shop bling in intention. mario movie is a video someone found, wii shop bling is a video someone within the group created. it was continued out of mutual respect and has a trend, but should not be defined as a meme.
leaving source combos as out-of-the-way "rips referencing" categories is fine, as to not confuse them for actual meme sources that are individually utilized in rips, it's fine.
~~ i think this is different from athletic doctor since the rip "Main Theme - Wii Shop Channel" is based on the original mashup by toonlink. I agree that this category should be renamed, but also think that the afformentioned rip should be included in this category.~~ (see https://discord.com/channels/787504555763826738/1363335604863111298/1363338677467484303)
~~ i think this is different from athletic doctor since the rip "Main Theme - Wii Shop Channel" is based on the original mashup by toonlink. I agree that this category should be renamed, but also think that the afformentioned rip should be included in this category.~~ (see https://discord.com/channels/787504555763826738/1363335604863111298/1363338677467484303)
I'm confused. "Main Theme - Wii Shop Channel" is already in the category. (Currently, Wii Shop Bling redirects to this rip but that's just because it makes the most sense to go there. We would change it to a regular article covering toonlink's mashup.)
my mistake. I did not see that it was already in the category. In this case, I fully support
the name “Wii Shop Bling” is in reference to the mashup not on the channel, main theme - wii shop channel is “Wii Shop Bling V2”
mario brothers movie is not equal to wii shop bling in intention. mario movie is a video someone found, wii shop bling is a video someone within the group created. it was continued out of mutual respect and has a trend, but should not be defined as a meme.
leaving source combos as out-of-the-way "rips referencing" categories is fine, as to not confuse them for actual meme sources that are individually utilized in rips, it's fine.
rock my forum is a video someone in the group created and it's still the main idea of a meme
a lot of my opinion on these two is coming from how i'd mentally define a meme vs a reference joke. (coming up after the slowmode wears off...)
i have a few more reservations about this one, i think itd be good to define the seperate trends of wii shop and hotline bling too. i think its a meme tho
aware of that, im just bringing attention that we may need to figure out if these memes should be like subpages of this one or not/other possibilities later on
"other possibilities" is more what im leaning on im not using 100% of my brain rn
no doubt about it, although both wii shop and hotline bling are also memes on their own
Tallying up.
Summary: We will convert "Rips referencing Wii Shop Bling" to a normal meme category called "Rips featuring Wii Shop Bling".
Support votes : 13 / 14 (92.8%)
- Turret
- Fezaki
- Samantha
- N / Eden
- Notascryptic
- ThisGreenDingo
- bruno
- circunflexo
- minindo
- Stump
- Arthur101
- thetelescope
Restructure votes 
: 0 / 14 (0%)
- [None]
Oppose votes : 1 / 14 (7.14%)
- Mick
Result: Approved.