Jump to content

SiIvaGunner Wiki:Meme discussion/Log/19th: BotanicSage

From SiIvaGunner Wiki
April 19, 2025
01:56 TurretBot

Per the moot, this serves to address the category BotanicSage fakeouts, and whether it should be converted to a normal meme, i.e. Rips featuring BotanicSage, along with having other references to BotanicSage added to it.

History/Current situation regarding the category (from the moot):

Made in 2018 (the beforetimes), this category documents a series of rips where BotanicSage is credited as the composer. These are also rips that reference BotanicSage's mashups obviously, but the composer line is essentially the only thing gatekeeping other references to BotanicSage from this category. Which kind of just feels like an old category with an outdated design to me?

Note for clarity: Since the category already exists, "oppose" in this context means "do nothing". If one believes this should not be categorized at all, that is a restructure.

01:58 TurretBot

might restructure my own proposal idk

02:05 Mick the Squirrel

for me. calling botanicsage a meme is really stretching the term, he's just a semipopular mashup guy that of course would be referenced within a channel of this context. The main ideas of his mashups are too scattered within the concept of music to coalesce as something cohesive, fakeouts of this nature can occur in other contexts (fools 2023), it's nothing special enough to dub as a meme.

i wouldn't mind if it were restructure-deleted, but this category doesn't seem like an issue in its current state, there is just nothing else like it. weird obscure wiki pages and categories are harmless...

02:06 TurretBot

this is probably the one that does make sense as a rips by joke since it is more about the composer credit than the actual rip

02:07 Heboyi

mick said my opinions on this in a well thought out manner before I could

02:08 Eden342

Per what Mick said.

02:10 Samanthamk

per mick

02:14 Nuc1eusknight

what the fuck

02:15 Nuc1eusknight

this shit is ASS!

02:25 Chickennugget12352

:XD:

02:26 Mick the Squirrel

homer hate botanic sage

02:27 Nuc1eusknight

gomer

02:49 Brunocoolgamers

same as the triple q propal

April 20, 2025
16:03 Stump-7

no

18:05 Arthur10123

I disagree with changing this to a normal meme category, I agree with Mick's points

19:46 CYLITM

Per Mick

April 26, 2025
17:15 Mobbz.Co

Not enough rips. Next Question.

00:04 Mobbz.Co

Forwarded: Any final thoughts before i shut this down in 2 and a half hours?

00:13 Stump-7

Forwarded: No, not really

00:51 Mobbz.Co

ok

00:54 Mobbz.Co

TurretBot #DestroyTheDynablade you probablyimplied ur vote but can you add ur voting emoji for all 3 threads please, just to confirm nvm

00:56 Mick the Squirrel

implied votes dont exist

01:30 Mobbz.Co
  • Final Results/Final Tally

(11 Oppose 's) (100%) -mick -Heboyi -Eden -Samantha -lucas -melcus hubert -bruno -stump -Arthur -CYLTM -HHGregg Scene (me)

(0 Support ) (0%)

(0 Restructure 's) (0%)

Decision: Rejected. It has been decided that BotanicSage is not a meme.


Debug data: