SiIvaGunner Wiki:Moot/Archive

The following is a list of archived moot changes.

July 2022

Category:Series navboxes must now meet all of the following criteria:

The number of links in the navboxes must be at least 5 (7-0)
We should not have navboxes within other navboxes (6-0)

We are going to remove the Composers series navboxes (8-0)
We will replace the Companies series navboxes with a list format that will be finalized and proposed by User:Pokemonfreak777 during the next moot (8-0)

August 2022

We will convert all Companies navboxes (currently in Category:Series navboxes#By companies to a List of video games by companies list in the same format as pokemonfreak's proposal User:Pokemonfreak777/List of video games by company (Proof of Concept) - 9-0 Support –
- For posterity, the proposal converts each company navbox into a section on "List of video games by company".
- Each navbox's sections are be converted to a subsection
As per Mick the Squirrel's suggestion, game navboxes will be placed the top of the relevant company's section (e.g. a navbox for Doom will be placed at the top of the Id Software section) - 9-0 Support –
List of rips referencing YouTubers does not need its own category, and its current category, "Category:Rips referencing YouTubers", will be removed from the wiki. - 9-0 Support –
- Ironwestie will double-check the list with AutoWikiBrowser before removing the category.
The three Trailer Theme (Livestream Version) - Sonic Mania articles will be merged into a single article - 10-0 Support – ** Note: although Padgriffin was not present to present the topic, the idea of merging the articles had been brought up previously by multiple wiki contributors so the topic was discussed anyway
a e s t h e t i c and its category will be removed, as it is not a SiIvaGunner meme. - 10-0 Support –

September 2022

Uncategorized files on outdated forum boards will be put into a Wiki forum images category (4-2-0)
- We decided against deleting these files (1-2-3)
Uncategorized files only used by editors for personal use (i.e. on their user pages) will be put into Category:Wiki editor images (6-0-0)
- Pokemonfreak777 volunteered to make the lists of files that suit this criteria. Ironwestie will categorize the images once this is complete.
Template:MusicMemes will be replaced with Template:MemeNav, as they are redundant. (5-0-0)
- We decided against replacing MusicMemes with the new one proposed by Mick the Squirrel. (1-0-4)
Template:Album will now automatically format Bandcamp and YouTube playlist links and will italicize previous and next links (6-0-0)
The "See also" section on album pages will be replaced with a Template:See also link at the top of the track list (5-0-0)
We briefly discussed a new process for when to discuss memes, frequently ripped tracks, series navboxes, and contributor lists. We will discuss more at the next moot. (no vote)

It was also announced that moot times will now be expressed in Coordinated Universal Time (i.e. "11 PM UTC") instead of Pacific Time (i.e. "4 PM Pacific") from now on.

October 1, 2022

The next moot will be in two weeks' time: October 15, 2022 at 11:00 PM UTC (7-0-0)
For single-source memes^{[note 1]}:

Memes must be used in at least 30 rips.
Memes must be used by at least 3 rippers.
Memes associated with channel event(s) should also have a presence outside of them.

- A fourth suggested point, "Memes should be relevant to the channel's lore," was rejected with a vote of 0-2-4, primarily because the point would not apply to most modern memes due to the abscence of lore.
We will revisit the rest of Pokemonfreak777's proposal about memes in the next moot, specifically the sections about multi-source memes^{[note 1]} and significance. Mick the Squirrel's proposal about the Mr. Krabs meme will be tabled after these sections have been discussed.
Category:Visual artists should include drawn art and original design artists, not contributors who do video editing or a single joke scribble (for example, in Wood Man birthday remixes) (7-0-0)
We will make a gallery subpage for Visual artists (including those that do not yet have a page) (8-0-0)
- We will exclude art credits that have not been made public yet (e.g. CCC art credits) (7-1-0)
The pages in the following subsections of User:Pokemonfreak777/List of uncategorized files by location will be categorized as follows:

Fandom-related: FANDOM images (a new category) (5-0-0)
Used in templates: Template images (a new category) (5-0-0)
JOEJOE'S BIZZAERE JOJOKE/Gallery: Bonus media (5-0-0)

- The other lists in the proposal will be tabled to next meeting

October 15, 2022

The criteria for the Sans is Ness meme will be qualified to the following criteria
- Only songs that specifically reference Sans (e.g. "sans." and "MEGALOVANIA") should count (only EarthBound songs, not MOTHER/MOTHER 3 songs)[...] (6-0-0)
- Only Game Theory references that specifically point to the "Sans is Ness" video or used in the context of Undertale/EarthBound music should count.[...] (6-0-0)
Rips that end with special, parenthetical parts of their titles (e.g. (removed), (August 18, 2022)) that are not part of the actual rip's title will be reformatted so that the parenthetical parts appear smaller:

The titles will be reformatted using {{DISPLAYTITLE:Title <small>(example)</small>}} (6-0-2)
Links to these pages on List of songs featuring in rips or in the "References in other rips" section of a game's category page should be formatted with the <small> tags as well (5-3-0)

New guideline for the rip list on event pages (this does not apply for events that don't have any non-event related rips in them):
- All rips related to events be in bold so that its easy way of seeing what is and what is not in a event (6-0-0)
- Rips that have been noted as some importance to the day but not related to the event in question should be in italics so that it can be easy to see them and understand what they mean (6-0-0)
- If there are too many or too little rips that are not apart of the event then we do not include them on the page (5-1-0)

November 2022

We will create a page called "Notable upload dates" as drafted by MSL925 the fox. The criteria: The holiday or occasion celebrated must have celebrations from two different years at minimum (7-0-0)
We will split the List of playlists page similarly to "List of songs featured in rips" and other lists. Specifically. by playlist name (0-E, K-O, P-T, U-Z) (5-1-0)
Coconut Gun is not a meme, it's just a part of Donkey Kong and DK Rap that isn't distinct enough to have its own page. The Coconut Gun page will be deleted or merged into another page. (4-1-0)
- We'll merge the contents of the current Coconut Gun page into the DK or DK rap page (5-1-0)
We'll remove this criterion for memes: 2. Memes must be used by at least 3 rippers.. Our current rules will be:
1. Memes must be used in at least 30 rips.
2. Memes associated with channel event(s) should also have a presence outside of them.
(6-1-0)
We tabled the discussion on some sources with more than 30 uses until we have more rules for memes.
We will remove the "Indirect contributors" section of the "List of contributors" page. (5-1-0)
To make meme page names consistent with their "Rips featuring" categories, we will rename the meme page and names for the following pairs (8-0-0):
- New: Eggnog (previously "Life Jacket Kid")
- Hate Not The Wind, Spring Blossoms ~ Eternal Wind ("Hate not the Wind, Spring Blossoms ~ Eternal Wind")
- The Time Is Now ("John Cena")
- Let's Do This ("Home Depot")
- Love Live! ("Love Live")
- Mr. Krabs ("Mr Krabs")
- My Little Pony ("My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic")
- Scatman John ("Scatman")
- The Love Plug ("Love Plug")
- Touhou Project ("Touhou")
- U.N. Owen Was Her? ("U.N. Owen was Her?")
- S.L.A.B. Freestyle ("Chip tha Ripper")

December 2022

We will make the following changes to the List of SiIvaGunner memes page:
- We will remove the "Other variants" and "Date of origin" sections from the list (6-0-0)
- We will add a short description at the start of the article and make the list a main article (6-0-0)
- We will use ironwestie's bot to fix the issue with the parser function calls limit (6-0-0)
- We will organise the list alphabetically (6-0-0)
We will label the following sources as channel memes (6-0-0):
- Dreamscape
- Yo Home to Bel-Air
- Party Rock Anthem
- Plastic Love
- Seinfeld Theme
- September
- X Gon' Give It to Ya
- 热爱105°C的你

January 2023

We will make the following changes to how mm2wood and "Wood Man Stage" are portrayed on the wiki:
- Rename the "Rips featuring mm2wood" category to "Rips featuring Wood Man Stage" (4-1-0)
- Merge the mm2wood and Wood Man Stage articles, while keeping the contents of both (4-1-0)
- Keep mm2wood listed on the List of SiIvaGunner memes using a redirect (2-3-0)
- Keep rips of "Wood Man Stage" that use mm2wood in its "Rips featuring category" (5-0-0)
When there are two or more rips with same title, the older ones will get date labels (6-1-0)
We will move Pokemonfreak777's List of video games by company onto the main wiki (6-0-0)

February 2023

We will make the following changes to how certain types of rips are documented on the wiki:
- SGFR rips will be counted as rips featuring the tracks they are centered around. (8-0-0)
- Rips of fusion collabs that are original to SiIva (such as the ones listed in the SiIvaGunner's Original Fusion Collabs playlist) will be counted as rips featuring tracks. Rips of fusion collabs that are not original to SiIva (such as the kirbtunes ones) will be counted as rips of a track. (5-1-0)
- For rips of fake games, if the title of the track is original, then the track featured should count as a song featured, while if the title is of an existing song, then that track would count as a track of. (6-1-1)
- Fanmade arrangements of songs that are ripped should count as rips of the original song. (7-1-0)

March 2023

We will unofficially label Pitbull as not a channel meme for the time being until proper critiria for multi-source memes are finalised. Their rips featuring category will not be removed for the time being. (6-0-0)
We will create articles for the KfAD2 MOJO!! interviews. (4-1-0)
The "Tweet images" category will be redefined as a "Social media images" category that will include all images posted on the channel's official twitter and YT community posts tab. (4-0-0)
We will not make certain articles on the wiki have themes different to the default one. (0-2-2)

April 2023

KFAD Mojo articles will have the following formatting rules when documented on the wiki:
- They will be placed into a category called "MOJO!! articles". (4-0-0)
- Articles on interviews will go in a sub-category called "MOJO!! interviews". (4-0-0)
- The infobox for these articles will include the following: Name, date, and characters featured. (4-0-0)
- The body of these articles will have the following formatting: (4-0-0)

  "Article name" is a high quality article/interview from the King for Another Day Tournament MOJO!!.
  [Summary of article]
  [Transcript of article]
  [Trivia]

The following tracks will have their "References in other rips" sections formatting updated in their respective game's category articles:
- The list for "Dancing Mad" will be arranged like this from now on: (4-0-0)

 Dancing Mad: OMORI - OMORI
      Movement 1: Majora's Mask Battle - The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask, End of Days (Endgame Map Screen) - Shovel Knight
      Movement 2: Main Theme - Vine
      Movement 3: PAPYRUS’ COOL SONG (Kickstarter) - Undertale
      Movement 4: Wood Man Fusion Collab

- The section for "One-Winged Angel" will be formatted into one list. (3-1-0)
The article and category for the meme "热爱105°C的你" will be renamed to "Super Idol". (3-2-0)

May 2023

We will not make categories that classifie games by VGM composers and consoles. (0-0-5)
We will classify "FORTNITE SONG!!!" by Misha as a channel meme. (2-2-0)
We will rename the meme "Patched Plains" to "The Noble Haltmann". (2-2-1)

June 2023

We will label the following sources as memes:
- Big Time Rush (includes songs from across the series) (5-0-0)
- Os Barões da Pisadinha (includes arrangement rips that use their instruments and regular rips that use their songs as a joke) (5-0-0)
- Koum süsser Tod (5-0-0)

July 2023

Pokemonfreak's alternate proposal for critiria regarding multi-source memes will be moved to the manual of style with a grace period of one month before it comes into effect. Suggestions for the critiria will be open during this period and will be considered.
A category called "SiIvaGunner games and mods" will be made. It will included all games and mods that were officially released through the channel.
- In addition to this, the categories for the playlists Friday Night Funkin' and Friday Night Funkin' Mods will be labeled as subcategories of this one.

August 5, 2023

We will lower the number of known uses criteria for single-source memes on the wiki from 30 to 25. (7-0-0)
We will add a section to the wiki's content policy that prohibits the creation of navboxes centred around composers and artists. This rule will have a list of exceptions to it, and any additions to it will need to be decided on in moots. (8-0-0)
- The composer navboxes that will be the current exceptions to this rule will be the ones for PSY, Tim Follin, Hideki Naganuma and Yoko Shimomura (8-0-0)
- We will remove the navbox for Yuzo Koshiro (8-0-0)
We will delete the comic book series navbox, and in its place we will make separate navboxes for Marvel, DC and Garfield. (5-1-0)
We will create a new category called "Original remixes". This will include all arrangements/remixes that are done for SGFR and both KFADs, and we will no longer label SGFR tracks as rips. KFAD tracks will still be seen as rips due to them being from fake games. (7-0-0)
- The current "Remixes" category will be redefined to only be about rips that include remix elements. (7-0-0)
- Rips of SGFR and KFAD remixes, such as those made during April Fools 2023, will be treated as rips. (7-0-0)
We will propose to make the following amendment to iron's draft on event criteria: (6-0-0)

Examples of themes that are not strong enough to count as an event on their own include:
* Spelling words with rip titles
* Having multiple rips that are of a certain length
* Having multiple rips with the same mix name

August 19, 2023

The following changes to the multi-source meme primary criteria were made:

Lowered the number of rips needed for the following sections: (5-0-0)
- Depth requirement (40 -> 35)
- Breadth requirement (20 -> 15)
- Additional source requirement (30-> 25)
The following were added to the multi-source meme secondary criteria:
- Meme has at least 1 related multi-day event or 3 related single-day events (4-1-0)
- Meme has at least 1 related album (contents only, cover/name does not count) (4-1-0)
- Meme is associated with the channel's lore (3-2-0)
- Source has a rip from at least one fake game (4-0-0)
- Source has at least one game that has three rips of one or more non-existent tracks (4-0-0)
- Source has ten related sources that have each been referenced at least once (4-1-0)

September 2023

We will incorporate pokemonfreak's formatting rules for the list of songs featured in rips into the Lists section of the wiki's manual of style. (5-0-0)
We will make a character page for the Joke-Explainer 7000. (5-0-0)
We will create a category called "YTPMV rips" that will include rips that meet the following definition: (3-2-1)

A rip is defined as a YTPMV if it has sources pitch-shifted to the track along with visuals that are in-sync with the audio.

October 2023

We will create a "Rips referencing Athletic Doctor" category that will contain rips that reference the "Athletic Theme (PAL Version) - Super Mario World" rip. Rips that meet one of the following set of criteria would count as a reference to the rip: (5-0-0)

* Recreations of the original rip using other versions of "Athletic Theme"
* Rips that place the melodies of "Witch Doctor" and "Athletic Theme" next to each other, or at the same time
* Inverses of the original rip (e.g. He's Quagmire - Family Guy Video Game!, Athletic Theme (NTSC Version) - Super Mario World)
* Rips of other Super Mario World songs that use the PAL Version mix name and primarily feature a joke relating to the band Cartoons
* Rips of other games that use the PAL Version mix name and primarily use the Cartoon's version of "Witch Doctor"

We will split the idol series navbox into navboxes for Love Live, The idolmaster, Vocaloid and Hololive based on Maggie's draft. User:Peacock Roy/sandbox (4-0-0)
We will split the List of playlists and List of songs featured in rips lists by individual letter. (3-2-0)
We will split The Flintstones navbox into separate navboxes for The Flintstones, The Simpsons and Family Guy. (5-0-0)

November 2023

We will make a category for rips made by their original composers. It will be called "Rips made by original composers" and will have the following category description: (5-0-0)

Rips made by their original composers.

We will make the category "Rips with original AI vocals" with the following description: (5-1-0)

Rips with rip-exclusive vocals made with AI.

We will make a character article on the 8-Bit Beast. (4-0-0)
We will make an article for "A Cruel Angel's Thesis". (5-0-0)
The link to the wiki's Discord server on the main moot page was fixed.

December 2023

We will make pages for each season on the channel where they are explained in more depth. (7-0-0)
We will make a character article for Takane Shijou. (5-0-0)

January 2024

We will make the formatting seen on Arthur's Season 1 draft the standard formatting for season articles. (7-0-0)
- For season articles, we will have a "Memes" section detailing major memes used in the season being covered, which will also have a sub-section titled "Other memes" in it. (7-0-0)
We will make a rips featuring category for the character Tito Dick. (6-0-0)
We will rename the event category "Reboot" to "SilvaGunner: Rebooted", and rename the playlist category "SilvaGunner: Rebooted" to "SilvaGunner: Rebooted (playlist)". (4-1-0)
We will move the "Uploads" navbox in the lists of uploads to the top of the pages instead of the very bottom. (4-0-0)
We will make a composer navbox for Toby Fox. (5-0-0)

February 3, 2024

We will split the "General channels" portion of List of rips referencing YouTubers into subpages alphabetically to make it easier to navigate. For the other sections of the list, we will keep them as is for now (pending another discussion) and put them into another subpage called "Other". (6-0-0)
We will upload hidden tracks from albums to the wiki as audio files (8-0-0)
We voted not to create articles for unofficial Christmas Comeback Crisis albums by dante, Madinstance, and Aps17. (1-2-5)
We will change the template images for the following templates:
- Template:Incomplete list (8-0-0)
- Template:Incomplete transcript (8-0-0)
- Template:Cleanup (5-3-0)
- Template:Incomplete (4-3-1)
- Template:Stub (8-0-0)
- Template:BEANED (4-4-0)
We will make a page for the 7th Anniversary Collage using the format Nackattack made. (7-1-0)

February 10, 2024

We will no longer treat the SG Art Team and SGFR as individual channel contributors. (6-0-0)
We will not make a composer navbox for Porter Robinson. (0-0-5)
We will make the following changes to how aliases of artists are treated on the list of songs referenced in rips: (4-1-0)
- We will include only major aliases
- We will make separate entries on the lists of songs featured in rips for each one, with each linking to the main alias
- We will include entries associated with said aliases under the respective alias instead of the main alias

March 2, 2024

We will not use years instead of seasons for lists of contributions (1-1-5)
We will label THE iDOLM@STER series as a multi-source meme on the wiki. (4-2-1)
We will not make a navbox for The Living Tombstone. It would have contained one contributor article, 3-4 memes, one game (In Sound Mind), and related games (like FNaF and Tattletail). (0-1-5)
We will make a category called "Rips affected by the SiIvaGunner Termination" which will include the eight rips that were removed by Sony Music Entertainment Japan that caused the termination, as well as the nine rips that were removed by the team to prevent further strikes during that period. (6-0-0)

March 16, 2024

We will move Arthur101's "Wiki resources and file guides" list to the main namespace, link to it in the top navigation bar, and link to it in "Policies and guidelines". (8-0-0)
We will delete Category:YouTubers and remove the category from the pages that have it. (9-0-0)
We will create a category for SilvaGunner, GilvaSunner, SiIvaGunner, Flustered Fernando, TimmyTurnersGrandDad, VvvvvaVvvvvvr, SiIvaGunner2, The High Quality Podcast and SG Art Team. The category is called "Ripping platforms", and it covers "YouTube channels ran for the purpose of uploading rips, or content relating to ripping". (3-4-1)

April 6, 2024

We will rename the "MAXIMUM/ULTIMATE QUALITY ACHIEVED" album articles to be "MAXIMUM/ULTIMATE QUALITY ACHIEVED (album)" and give the former titles to their respective videos. (10-0-0)
We will remove the contributor categories from the "Maximum Quality Achieved" article for contributors that only had their rips sampled as part of the set. (10-1-0)
Summary: We will choose the following theming for the Incomplete list template to be themed around DK, specifically an image of DK with the Coconut Gun and the caption "If you know the words, you can join in too!". Four images were suggested. The vote count was as follows:
1. The CCC image / rip2 thumb - no votes
2. The DK rap image - three votes
3. Coconut Gun image - six votes
4. 7th anniversary collage art - one vote
5. No change (Gangnam Style) - no votes
6. No preference (i.e. your vote will not be counted towards any total) - one vote
We will not replace the theming for Template:Delete with theming for Ajit Pai instead of theming around the Voice. (0-2-7)
We will not change the theming of Template:Tracking_category to be themed around the broken Gadget bot from the CCC (0-6-4).

April 20, 2024

We will add audio previews in the infobox for memes and frequently ripped tracks, based on the music samples used on Wikipedia. These previews would be short samples of the subjects of their articles, lasting at most 30 seconds. They would be categorized under "Category:Audio previews". (8-0-0)
We will follow the common stylization of hololive production to use a lowercase H in "hololive". (6-2-0)
We will use the official name formatting order for hololive talent. That is, we will order the names with last name followed by first name (i.e. family name followed by given name). (7-0-0)
We will not make a mandate on the capitalization of "the" if it is at the beginning of a name (i.e. "So said the Voice." versus "So said The Voice."). Capitalization will be on a case-by-case basis. (3-6-0)

May 4, 2024

We will change the "Rips featuring Mr. Krabs" category into a "Rips featuring Electric Zoo" that will be focused on the song of the same name and the Mr. Krabs "Beep, Bop" source. All other Mr. Krabs sources from the current category that are not related to the category's new definition will be removed. (7-0-0)
We will label SpongeBob SquarePants as a multi-source meme. (5-1-0)
We did not approve a proposal to split the Lists of contributions by putting album exclusive rips (a.k.a. "tracks") on a secondary list within the contributor's list of contributions. (2-3-2)

May 11, 2024

We will set a rule that: If jokes related to MARIO BROTHERS MOVIE meet the meme criteria, when the pages are created they may be connected together in some form, via the use of a section mentioning their usage in MBM as well as related pages being included on a See Also section. This will also apply to a main MARIO BROTHERS MOVIE page as well in the future if that reaches the criteria as well. (5-2-0)
s's (an apostrophe with an S) should be used for singular nouns that end in S and s' should be used for plurals. For example, 'Grand Dad's', 'James's', and 'dogs' (6-4-0)
We will create a category called "Rips of fake tracks" with the following description: (9-1-0)

[[Rips]] where the advertised track is not actually present in the listed source material or does not exist at all, but the source material itself does exist.

We will change the code of Template:Navbox and Template:Navbox_series to the code written for the MarioGunner wiki (https://mariogunner.fandom.com/wiki/Template:Navbox?oldid=606 and https://mariogunner.fandom.com/wiki/Template:Navbox_series?oldid=607). (5-1-1)
- The main changes are: The height is shortened, saving scroll space; Roughly center-aligned section text; Allows subseries (i.e. Mario Kart, Party, and Tennis) to be represented as child subsections actually built into the navbox
- We will convert the navboxes over time by first importing the code to a /Sandbox subpage, convert the navboxes' code using the sandbox, and once everything is done, we will move the /Sandbox code to the main page and use a bot to finish the changes.
- Note: Ironwestie will test the navbox code and report any issues that he finds. If all is well, the changes may be made. Ironwestie's testing will be done in approximately two weeks. Until then, please do not implement the changes.
We will create a category for redirects called Category:Redirects and a subcategory called "Category:Rename redirects" with the description: "Redirects for a former title of the target" (3-5-0)

May 18, 2024

We will change the “Rips featuring Andrew Tate” category into a “Rips featuring Bumble Bee” category. The Andrew Tate article will be rewritten to be about “Bumble Bee”, while keeping the info on Andrew Tate’s connection to the meme. (9-2-0)
We will implement overcast's proposed change to the wiki's contributor policy listed here: (6-1-0)

User:Overcast07/Moot#Policy_change

We will implement overcast's Infobox for contributor categories from the templement sandbox. (6-1-0)

Template:Contributor/sandbox

We will add a section in the wiki's manual of style on how arrangements should be described in rip articles that will establish that "arrangement in the style of X" normally implies that the instrumentation of X has been used, in order to allow awkward and grammatically dubious constructions like "arrangement in the instruments and style of X" to be simplified to "arrangement in the style of X". (5-2-0)
We will rename the category "Short videos" to "Shorts" and no longer label it as a playlist on the wiki. (5-1-1)

May 25, 2024

We will pause the creation of: (9-0-0)
- Meme articles (redlinks already in Template:MemeNav may have pages made for them)
- Meme categories
- New additions to Template:MemeNav
...Until a system for meme restructuring is proposed and agreed upon in a moot OR 6 months have passed. (This is November 25, 2024 at 4:58 PM PDT)
Addendum: If agreed upon in a moot, one meme at a time may be added and bypass the pause.

We voted not to create a "Completed OSTs" category, which would have had the following description had it been approved: (3-3-3)

This includes game original soundtracks who have had the following ripped by SiIvaGunner:
- Base game tracks
- Official album releases, including unused tracks if they ever got an official release alongside the base game
- If there are port-specific tracks, they should not be counted towards completion of this OST, unless the playlist is specific to that port
Fake games will not be a part of this category.

June 1, 2024

We will change the wiki's background from black to dark gray (specifically to #111111) (6-0-0)
We will create subpages on the list of rips referencing media for Video games (with no playlist), Web media, and Companies. (6-0-0)

June 8, 2024

We will create a category "Rips featuring original content by SiIvaGunner". It will contain rips that reference original compositions by SiIvaGunner, such as KFAD, SGFR, and fake games such as Jet Set Radio Evolution. This will not include rips that reference other rips created by the channel (i.e. Athletic Doctor). (5-3-1)
We will no longer be using the MarioGunner navbox code after testing has found multiple issues. (8-0-0)
- We will instead test the compatibility of dev.fandom/Wikipedia and, in a later moot, determine which of the two versions to use. (7-1-0)
We will classify "Faz o sample de Guitarra" by DJ Marquinho as a channel meme. (6-0-0)

July 6, 2024

We will split the current event navbox to new navboxes split by season. (8-0-0)
We will import the dev.fandom Navbox and replace the current templates using our outdated Template:Navbox with ones created for the dev.fandom Navbox on the test-123 wiki. We will convert the series navboxes to use the dev.fandom Navboxes over time. After there are no more navboxes using Navbox series, we will remove "Navbox series" from the template names. (5-0-0)
We will make story arcs into separate pages from their associated events. (4-0-0)
We will move "List of video games by company" to Pokemonfreak777's user page, effectively removing it from the main wiki namespace. (6-0-0)

July 13, 2024

We will rename "List of songs featured in rips" to "List of musicians featured in rips" to more accurately describe its contents. (10-0-0)
- Addendum: due to the approval of the second proposal, the article will instead be renamed to "List of references to musicians".
We will rename the lists of things featured in rips to use a "List of references to X" format. (8-0-0)
We will make the Family Guy theme song a sub-meme of Family Guy. (5-2-1)

July 20, 2024

We will remove the current composer navboxes (except for PSY). (4-2-1)
We will create categories for video game music composers in the format 'Games scored by X' (using automation as an initial base). (5-1-1)
We will create a meme article and category for Nicolas Cage. (6-0-0)

August 3, 2024

We will make a category for "MARIO BROTHERS MOVIE". The category will include usages of sound effects from the video, the video's visuals, and of the mashup "TiKToK Up the Dancefloor". (6-0-0)
- Specifically, we will make the category as a "Rips featuring..." category, as opposed to a "Rips referencing..." category. (5-1-0)
We will add Wikipedia's "Current event template" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Current_event_templates) to the wiki, to be added to ongoing channel events pages. (4-0-0)

August 17, 2024

We will classify Desmond the Moon Bear as a meme. (4-2-0)
We will allow it to be acknowledged on the wiki when a contributor was removed from the team (or blacklisted from the community) due to pedophilia, under the following conditions. (5-2-0)
- Publicly viewable sources from qualified individuals (i.e. backroom members) acknowledging these reasons are available.
- Said sources are cited specifically when adding the information to the wiki.
- Said reasons are listed as neutrally as possible to convey the pertinent information without attacking the individual.
We will remove the "uploads" sections from the King for a Day and the King for Another Day navboxes. (5-1-0)

October 2024

We voted not to split the Inspector Gadget category to separate out instances of the theme as its own category. (1-2-2)
- Instead, we will rename the category to be solely focused on the theme, with instances not of the theme moved to the appropriate list of references.
We will split the Simpsons category to separate out instances of the theme as its own category. (5-0-0)

November 2024

We will unlock MemeNav, but continue the other main rules of The Meme Pause (no creating, deleting, or restructuring categories unless they are discussed using the system below) (5-1-0)
We will make a new, real discussion channel in this discord server to replace THE FINAL MEME DISCUSSION THREAD, focused on the creation or deletion of meme articles and categories. (4-1-1)
- We will create a thread channel for this purpose
- Discussion is locked to verified members
- One proposal is open a week per person, with the option to extend the discussion by three days if a participant requests it
- A source passes and is considered a meme if at least 75% positive votes (and at least 7 people voting)
- Moderators will approve the discussion
- The establishment of an official baseline will carry on through discussion there.
- We will transcribe and archive meme discussions
We will create a role for trusted volunteers to approve, tally, and summarize discussions (4-2-0)

The system described will be trialed from 7:59 PM Pacific on November 25th to 7:59 PM Pacific on December 25th (i.e. 03:59, Nov 26 UTC to 03:59, December 26 UTC), and discussed in the moot following the trial's end date.

December 7, 2024

We voted not to group artist features on List of rips referencing musicians into a sublist under the artist's entry. (3-2-2)

For example:

== Pharrel Williams ==
* ADD SUV: see Uffie
[...]

...would have become:

== Pharrel Williams ==
[... Pharrel songs...]
*In other lists* [italics]
* ADD SUV: see Uffie

- Note: This vote narrowly missed the "two-thirds majority" rule with a ratio of three "support" votes to two "oppose" votes.

December 14, 2024

We will create a separate character article for the SiIva A.I., under the name "SiIva A.I.". (7-0-0)

January 2025

We will continue using the Meme discussion system (with some changes if voted on). (8-1-0)
- We will transition the meme discussion channel to a forum channel instead of a threads channel. The ⁠meme-discussion channel will serve as a place for freeform discussion, while the forum channel will be where memes are proposed. (7-0-0)
- We will allow non-verified members to participate in ⁠meme-discussion (the freeform channel), while the forum channel for meme proposals will continue to be restricted to verified members. (5-2-0)
- We will create a subpage for summaries of meme discussions. The discussion list's table will be updated to add a link to each proposal's summary. (6-0-0)
- We will change the responsibilities of Vote Approvers slighly. Instead of logging chat discussions, they must instead write summaries of the discussions. (5-0-0)
  - The full list of responsibilities for Vote Approvers is now:

* Closing threads after a week
* Extending threads, if requested
* Manually reading over and determining if threads came to a natural agreement
* Writing summaries of the discussions and posting them to the archive page
* Warning proposers if any rules (listed below) are accidentally ignored
* Locking proposal threads if the rules are intentionally ignored

February 1, 2025

We will reinstate the practice of linking rips that reference a particular rip on the referenced rip's page. In other words, pages on "List of references to SiIvaGunner" should include the rips that reference their rips. (8-1-0)
We will mark the following rips with unknown jokes (listed below) as stubs: (6-3-0)
We will create a infobox for Story arcs as per Arthur10123's draft. (8-0-0)
We voted not to create "musician" pages for composers such as Hiroyiuki Sawano, Hideki Naganuma, ZUN, and Porter Robinson. (1-2-6)
We voted not to create a category for "low-quality rips", i.e. rips that were removed because of bad taste / offensive content (1-1-7)

February 15, 2025

We will rename Category:Meme icons to Category:Meme images. (12-0-0)
We will create a category called "Rips with original live-action footage" (as a Category:Rips by joke subcategory) for any videos/rips that contain original live action footage. This would therefore include certain streams, MAGFest recordings, skits within rips, etc. (12-0-0)
We will change Nutshackwoodman34's page to "Reader and Jerome", updating the page's content to refer to both characters. (10-0-0)

March 1, 2025

We will rename the current event page "Season Mine" to "Start of Season Mine". (6-2-0)
We will make an article for SiIvaGunner's channel description, based on User:TurretBot/Channel description. (7-0-0)
We will move Pokemonfreak's three lists of undocumented rips to the SiIvaGunner Wiki namespace as "SiIvaGunner Wiki:Undocumented rips". (6-0-0)

March 15, 2025

We will create an official YouTube channel for the wiki. (7-1-0)
- Currently, the channel will be operated as a brand account channel, with the wiki staff and managers (selected by the wiki staff) operating it. The channel will be used to upload album exclusives and create/maintain automatic playlists.
We will move entries on List of placeholder names to the article for the respective album(s) if they only appear on one or two albums. This should make the information easier to maintain, since it will become more obvious when placeholder names are not listed (as the moved information will be shown directly after each album's track list). (6-1-0)
We will create a category for rips that only contain a single, unedited audio or video. The name will be discussed outside of the moot. (4-1-0)

April 5, 2025

We will implement subcategories with the naming scheme "Rips featuring xxxxx minor sources" for memes, according to Corb's Category Restructure Proposal. We will only change the 12 shell categories listed under "Categories With No Complications" under User:CorbCreates/Category Reorganization. The other categories will be handled through ⁠#meme-proposals. (5-1-0)
We voted not to create Category:Fusion arrangements, which would have contained 'fusions' ('Arrangements of five styles aside from the advertised track'). It would have contained the contents of Category:SiIvaGunner's Original Fusion Collabs aside from SiIvaGunner Art Fusion Collab and 7 Grand Dad Fusion Collab, as well as the rips in the Format section of Category:SiIvaGunner's Original Fusion Collabs#References in other rips (4-1-3)
We voted not to remove the Format section of Category:SiIvaGunner's Original Fusion Collabs#References in other rips (0-0-6)

April 19, 2025

We will allow TurretBot to create four threads regarding whether to convert the "Rips referencing" categories or cut them. (10-2-0)
We will implement the BringExternalLinkIconsBack extension to the wiki's CSS. (9-0-0)
We will make a a category for playlists on the channel that have been sorted. (7-2-0)

May 3, 2025

We voted not to create "List of third-party albums", a list that documents "third-party" albums. "Third party" meaning "anything other than official SiIvaGunner media" and "album" meaning "something containing at least one lossless audio track" (8-0-6)
- The list would have included collaborative albums (those where at least 5 different SiIvaGunner contributors' rips are present), solo albums (those which primarily consist of a single contributor's rips), other SiIvaGunner rip compilations (other albums which consist entirely of SiIvaGunner rips) and any other albums that contain SiIvaGunner rips (for which each relevant track should be listed on the page)
We voted not to create "Category:Rips included on third-party albums" (the category may also contain tracks) with the same definition above. (3-2-9)
- If this proposal passed, we would have also renamed Category:Non-SiIvaGunner album releases to "Category:Tracks from third-party sources" to avoid ambiguity
We will add sections to SiIvaGunner Wiki: Glossary for notable third-party albums, including Secret Silva and Gangnamcore, and allow articles to link to each album's entry (e.g. SiIvaGunner Wiki: Glossary#S for Secret Silva) (14-0-0)
- Redirects will also be created for these notable third-party albums (e.g. Secret SiIva --> SiIvaGunner Wiki:Glossary#S)

May 17, 2025

We will create a "list of characters" page which includes all characters who have made speaking or cameo appearances in SiIvaGunner story content (including individual videos that are not connected to the main SiIvaGunner lore). (8-0-0)
- The list will be in the form of a sortable table with the columns "Name", "Origin", "First appearance", "Date [of first appearance]" and "Notes", and will link to other articles that have more information about particular characters.
- The list of characters will be split into three sections for major characters, minor characters and cameos. The distinction between "major characters" and "minor characters" is loosely defined, but the terms should be used in the same way as on the existing lists of characters.
- The existing page at "Characters" will be renamed to "Figments" and restructured accordingly, and "Characters" will then be redirected to "List of characters".
We will create a page called "List of records" to organize various trivia. Examples of trivia that can be added include, but are not limited to: most viewed videos, longest video names, most disliked videos, etc. (7-1-0)
We will change the link for the album "." (a single period) from its current name of "-" (a single dash) to ". (album)" to make clear what it is and to make it more clickable. (7-0-0)

Notes

↑ ^1.0 ^1.1 Single-source memes are memes that only have one musical source associated with them. This is in contrast to multi-source memes that have multiple sources; for example The Beatles has multiple songs that could be used as memes

[source-definitions-1] 1.0 ^1.1 Single-source memes are memes that only have one musical source associated with them. This is in contrast to multi-source memes that have multiple sources; for example The Beatles has multiple songs that could be used as memes

[note 1]