SiIvaGunner Wiki:Moot/2023 August 05

This page is an archive of a community-wide discussion. This page is no longer live. Further comments should be made on its Talk Page rather than here so that this page is preserved as a historic record. Please do not modify it.

Log

• August 5, 2023 (Text)
• Moot Leader: Spottygamester

Agenda

Discussed

• Spottygamester - Lower the number of uses criteria for single-source memes from 30 to 25.
• Pokemonfreak777 - Revisit series navboxes' determination from July 2022 Moot
• Pokemonfreak777 - Split up Template:Navbox series comic book into the following navboxes suggested by User:Peacock Roy
• Spottygamester - Creating a new category for SGFR arrangements. Could possibly have KFAD arrangements in it as well, but needs to be discussed.
• Memmy - Establishing proper guidelines as to what counts as an event

Tabled for next meetings

August 19

• Pokemonfreak777 - Various topics related to the multi-source meme criteria (as many as time/attendance/other topics permits)

September 2

• ZachHasArrived - Add a YTPMV category for rips
• ZachHasArrived - Create a character page for the Joke-Explainer 7000
• ZachHasArrived - Create a "Rips referencing "Athletic Doctor"" category

Changes

• We will lower the number of known uses criteria for single-source memes on the wiki from 30 to 25. (7-0-0)
• We will add a section to the wiki's content policy that prohibits the creation of navboxes centred around composers and artists. This rule will have a list of exceptions to it, and any additions to it will need to be decided on in moots. (8-0-0)
  • The composer navboxes that will be the current exceptions to this rule will be the ones for PSY, Tim Follin, Hideki Naganuma and Yoko Shimomura (8-0-0)
  • We will remove the navbox for Yuzo Koshiro (8-0-0)
• We will delete the comic book series navbox, and in its place we will make separate navboxes for Marvel, DC and Garfield. (5-1-0)
• We will create a new category called "Original remixes". This will include all arrangements/remixes that are done for SGFR and both KFADs, and we will no longer label SGFR tracks as rips. KFAD tracks will still be seen as rips due to them being from fake games. (7-0-0)
  • The current "Remixes" category will be redefined to only be about rips that include remix elements. (7-0-0)
  • Rips of SGFR and KFAD remixes, such as those made during April Fools 2023, will be treated as rips. (7-0-0)
• We will propose to make the following amendment to iron's draft on event criteria: (6-0-0)

Examples of themes that are not strong enough to count as an event on their own include:
* Spelling words with rip titles
* Having multiple rips that are of a certain length
* Having multiple rips with the same mix name