Jump to content

SiIvaGunner Wiki:Moot/2022 October 01

From SiIvaGunner Wiki
This page is an archive of a community-wide discussion. This page is no longer live. Further comments should be made on its Talk Page rather than here so that this page is preserved as a historic record. Please do not modify it.

Log

Agenda

  • Ironwestie - Should we increase the frequency of moots (2 weeks)?
  • pokemonfreak777 - Discuss thresholds/criteria for memes/frequently ripped tracks/anything else that might need it (may need multiple meetings) (partially; see "Changes" section)
  • Mick - Remove Mr. Krabs as a meme and replace it with something else (skipped; see Changes section)
  • ZachHasArrived - Redefining "Sans is Ness" meme (skipped; the presenter was not present)
  • minindo (on behalf of overcast) - This issue [an issue about List of contributions pages that has been rescinded by overcast] (skipped and resolved)
  • Mick - How do we define visual artists?
  • Mick - Contributor art subpage gallery
  • ZachHasArrived - Reformatting rip pages with "special" titles (skipped; the presenter was not present)
  • pokemonfreak777 - should new categories be created for images in the following groups (Page comment, User thread, User blog, subsections under "Used on the wiki"), and if not, what existing category should they be in? (Reference)

Changes

  • The next moot will be in two weeks' time: October 15, 2022 at 11:00 PM UTC (7-0-0)
  • For single-source memes[note 1]:
  1. Memes must be used in at least 30 rips.
  2. Memes must be used by at least 3 rippers.
  3. Memes associated with channel event(s) should also have a presence outside of them.
    • A fourth suggested point, "Memes should be relevant to the channel's lore," was rejected with a vote of 0-2-4, primarily because the point would not apply to most modern memes due to the abscence of lore.
  • We will revisit the rest of Pokemonfreak777's proposal about memes in the next moot, specifically the sections about multi-source memes[note 1] and significance. Mick the Squirrel's proposal about the Mr. Krabs meme will be tabled after these sections have been discussed.
  • Category:Visual artists should include drawn art and original design artists, not contributors who do video editing or a single joke scribble (for example, in Wood Man birthday remixes) (7-0-0)
  • We will make a gallery subpage for Visual artists (including those that do not yet have a page) (8-0-0)
    • We will exclude art credits that have not been made public yet (e.g. CCC art credits) (7-1-0)
  • The pages in the following subsections of User:Pokemonfreak777/List of uncategorized files by location will be categorized as follows:
  1. Fandom-related: FANDOM images (a new category) (5-0-0)
  2. Used in templates: Template images (a new category) (5-0-0)
  3. JOEJOE'S BIZZAERE JOJOKE/Gallery: Bonus media (5-0-0)
    • The other lists in the proposal will be tabled to next meeting
  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 Single-source memes are memes that only have one musical source associated with them. This is in contrast to multi-source memes that have multiple sources; for example The Beatles has multiple songs that could be used as memes
Retrieved from "https://www.siivagunner.wiki/w/index.php?title=SiIvaGunner_Wiki:Moot/2022_October_01&oldid=397763"
Debug data: