Jump to content

SiIvaGunner Wiki:Meme discussion/Log/28th: Among Us in Real Life

From SiIvaGunner Wiki
April 28, 2025
11:18 ThisGreenDingo

"Among Us in Real Life" is an Among Us fan song by Rebecca Zamolo. Its primary reason for usage on the SiIvaGunner channel is to represent the broader, more central meme of Among Us.

In this proposal I have 3 options for you to choose from:

  1. "Among Us in Real Life" will have its page cut, its category put into an Among Us shell category in a similar fashion to Big Chungus and its information listed on the Among Us page in a similar fashion to Big Chungus. If you agree with this, support this proposal.
  2. "Among Us in Real Life" will have its page AND category cut, and no longer be considered a meme. If you agree with this, vote with a restructure stating you want to go with option 2.
  3. "Among Us in Real Life" will remain exactly as it is. If you agree with this, oppose this proposal.

I'll vote later once I can gauge a consensus, we are going to be focusing on one song at a time so please don't bring other Among Us songs into the conversation until we get to them in the next proposal.

11:19 Eden342

Doesn’t need a page or a category.

11:20 Stump-7

see above

11:21 Mick the Squirrel

option 2

11:21 Stump-7

why did among us in real life become a meme in the first place anyways

11:22 Mick the Squirrel

😃

11:22 GargameNga2025

the same reason most things did

Stump-7

why did among us in real life become a meme in the first place anyways

11:22 Eden342

My favorite number

11:23 Notascryptic

option 2

11:23 GargameNga2025

option 2

Stump-7

why did among us in real life become a meme in the first place anyways

11:23 TurretBot

option 2

11:24 ThisGreenDingo

it did not take long to gauge a consensus holy shit

11:25 ThisGreenDingo

rebecca ur cooked im afraid

11:26 TurretBot

also *its

11:26 ThisGreenDingo

thanks

11:41 Picaloyouhavenosauce

i think it is notable enough to where having at least a category is valuable information for the wiki to have. perhaps the page itself can be cut for lack of info specific to it, but the category should stay

11:45 ThisGreenDingo

that aligns with option 1 yea

11:46 Picaloyouhavenosauce

among us in real life is definitely a sub meme of among us so cutting it as a meme entirely is very rash to me

11:48 Madotsuki417

support for option one, i agree with circun among us in real life is a source that makes way more sense to be categorized as a submeme of among us and cutting it would be obviously weird lol

11:48 Picaloyouhavenosauce

would existing among us in real life rips just be put in the among us category?

11:49 Picaloyouhavenosauce

because that doesn't seem right to me, among us is such a varied source, way more than big chungus, so lumping everything into one "among us" category is not very useful

11:49 ThisGreenDingo

option 1 means the category stays in a shell for among us, and among us irl gets a blurb on the main page

11:50 Picaloyouhavenosauce

i mean if option 2 passes

11:50 ThisGreenDingo

option 2 means among us in real life gets nothing so probably not ideal if u want the category to stay

11:50 GargameNga2025

they would be in the among us meme category yea along w all the other fansongs

11:51 Madotsuki417

would option 2 mean among us gets put into the among us category (understandable) or its just no longer categorized at all (cringe)

11:52 GargameNga2025

its already in the list of fan media in the among us category (so its already in there)

11:52 ThisGreenDingo

i guess it means option 2 would make it in the list in the general among us category which isnt super ideal, i prefer option 1 but im still waiting to see where things go

11:53 Madotsuki417

id rather it be classed as an among us minor source tbh becuase thats what it is so yeah keeping my support, just wanted clarification on that

11:54 ThisGreenDingo

i think for simplicity just vote for option 1 and we'll return to wether it needs a blurb or not in another proposal

11:54 Picaloyouhavenosauce

this is weird i always thought among us in real life to be one of the more notable among us sub sources

11:54 ThisGreenDingo

same which is why the restructure votes all shocked me

11:54 Picaloyouhavenosauce

so seeing people want to cut it really surprised me yeah

11:55 Madotsuki417

this is probably a #MinorMemesMatter moment and yes i am making that a thing that was not a joke

11:55 Picaloyouhavenosauce

we're not making that a thing memmerly.

11:55 Madotsuki417

thoguh in the case of among us in real life its more of a minor sub meme idk.

Stump-7

see above

11:55 Stump-7

makes sense reading the takes

11:55 ThisGreenDingo

could this be one of those things where a song means more to the rippers than to the community

11:56 GargameNga2025

i dont think its any more notable than stop posting about among us or anything

ThisGreenDingo

could this be one of those things where a song means more to the rippers than to the community

11:56 Picaloyouhavenosauce

i mean maybe? ive never used it myself though

ThisGreenDingo

could this be one of those things where a song means more to the rippers than to the community

11:56 GargameNga2025

Probably its more notable to me in fanchannel contexts

GargameNga2025

i dont think its any more notable than stop posting about among us or anything

11:56 Madotsuki417

see my thing is i would also want that classed as an among us minor source or grouped in a wider among us category so my opinion isnt any different hearing that

11:56 Stump-7

hmm

11:57 Picaloyouhavenosauce

i agree

11:57 Stump-7

yeah cutting it as a meme entirely is a bit odd

11:58 Stump-7

it’s a very minor meme but a meme nonetheless

11:58 GargameNga2025

the general among us category includes all fan media so that stuff just being there is fine imo do they rly need much special treatment

11:59 ThisGreenDingo

also my new plan for this is this:

  • Part 1: Among Us IRL
  • Part 2: Airpod Shotty
  • Part 3: Among Us Trap Remix/Dead Body Reported
12:00 GargameNga2025

maybe i should just put fortnite on the life list

12:01 ThisGreenDingo

i think thats a good idea tbh

12:01 GargameNga2025

looking at the among us category has me nostalgic for the big list of fortnite fansongs

12:01 ThisGreenDingo

im not gonna vote on that cuz im not really invested in that but its a worthwhile discussion

GargameNga2025

looking at the among us category has me nostalgic for the big list of fortnite fansongs

12:02 Stump-7

out of curiosity what are you referring to from this

12:07 GargameNga2025

the rips featuring fortnite category that used to exist

Madotsuki417

would option 2 mean among us gets put into the among us category (understandable) or its just no longer categorized at all (cringe)

12:15 CorbCreates

All among us IRL rips are already in the rips featuring among us category due to the recent Shell Category Restructure proposal. If a rip is a solo rip of Among US IRL, it is in both rips featuring Among Us and rips featuring Among Us IRL, because Among Us IRL is a subcategory of Among Us

GargameNga2025

the general among us category includes all fan media so that stuff just being there is fine imo do they rly need much special treatment

12:16 Picaloyouhavenosauce

yes in my opinion due to the nature of the meme which ranges a wide variety of sources, biggest of them being among us trap remix and miscellaneous sound effects which aren't distinguishable enough to occupy separate categories. fansongs (and other memes like stop posting about among us and airpod shotty) differ a lot in what they are and how they're used from the main meme to the point where having its own category is justified if its notable enough as a submeme

12:21 CorbCreates

If Option 1 is voted, only the information page is deleted, and the information is moved to the general among us page. If option 2 is chosen, Among Us IRL is considered to simply be another use of Among Us. Uses of it will be included in a text list on the Among Us category page and will also be featured in the Among Us minor sources category (Just adding further clarification on what the 2 options are doing)

12:25 Brunocoolgamers

per circun

12:25 GargameNga2025

so its kinda just how much you value the info abt among us irl i think

12:28 Picaloyouhavenosauce

i dont really value the info bc theres not much there specific to among us irl itself it just started being used because its funny among us

12:30 Picaloyouhavenosauce

thats whats good about the subcategories thing we can have memes without like 5 info pages that basically say the same thing

15:29 Navag8r

agree with circun

15:36 Eden342

changed my vote per circun

18:53 Jlvs200s

echoing circun's thoughts on compressing Among Us IRL compression.

22:58 ThisGreenDingo

Currently support will need 12 votes if its going to pass

02:34 ASwitchDog

I’m always down to consolidate meme pages that cover the same broader topic

03:11 Gremmyblam63

Sure

04:33 ThisGreenDingo

man the voting majority percentage weight is so off because support is 9 out of 13 votes and restructure is still going to win at this point until support gets 12 votes

April 29, 2025
07:55 GoldM

Option 1

16:04 Arthur10123

option 1, I would rather keep the category

03:27 ThisGreenDingo

okay yea im gonna go with

May 2, 2025
05:00 CYLITM

option one

May 4, 2025
06:12 ThisGreenDingo

Tallying up! Support: (13 votes) 76.47%

  • circunflexo
  • memmy
  • Stump
  • bruno
  • Navag8r
  • eden
  • jlvs200s
  • aswitchdog
  • Grambam36
  • virivren
  • Arthur101
  • Me
  • CYLITM

Restructure: (4 votes) 23.53%

  • Mick
  • coolguy
  • Fezaki
  • TurretBot

Decision: Support: "Among Us in Real Life" will have its page cut, its category put into an Among Us shell category in a similar fashion to Big Chungus and its information listed on the Among Us page in a similar fashion to Big Chungus.

06:15 ThisGreenDingo

[CLOSED] Among Us in Real Life should be compressed into the main Among Us page

Retrieved from "https://www.siivagunner.wiki/w/index.php?title=SiIvaGunner_Wiki:Meme_discussion/Log/28th:_Among_Us_in_Real_Life&oldid=729399"
Debug data: